I have posted before about our efforts to teach our kids to navigate the world independently, and our occasional encounters with people who seem to think that navigating the world independently is a skill kids should develop spontaneously at approximately age 19 after having been bundled in body armor and bubble wrap up until that time. This week, though, I am bumping up against the edges of what I'm comfortable with myself.
We have one car, and we mostly like it that way. To clarify: my husband loves it that way, and I think it works pretty well. I've been making intermittent second-car noises as the kids' schedules get more complicated, but they remain intermittent.
My oldest son had a school activity on Saturday, and he had plans to go bowling afterward with friends. "I'll have the car," Elwood told him, "so you'll be on your own getting home. Get a ride or take the bus." Alex called me at 7:00 from a friend's phone -- his battery had died. In five more minutes he was going to cross the street and catch the next bus, he told me.
I thought this was a terrible plan.
It wasn't just any street; it was the big six-lane road with some of the heaviest traffic in town. I don't like crossing that road on foot myself, and the thought of my kid doing it after dark made me very uncomfortable. Assuming he froggered safely to the other side, he'd be walking through the mall parking lot (did I mention it was already dark?) to wait an indeterminate length of time at the bus stop (in the dark). In the event of a parking lot hit-and-run or skeeviness at the bus stop, he had no phone.
"Can't you ask a friend to drop you off at the bus stop?" I asked him, thinking even as I asked that getting in a car with a teenaged driver is about the riskiest thing he does in life. Nope, he said. Everyone else was heading in the opposite direction. I spluttered a bit, weighing the options. Should he call a taxi? Should I calm down and trust him? "Mom," he assured me, "I know how to cross a street."
He made it home quickly and safely, though I still have a little knot in my stomach as I'm typing out the story. And then tonight the very same question came up again. He was walking to a Boy Scout meeting in our neighborhood. Elwood thought it would be fine for him to walk home alone afterward. I didn't want him walking in the dark. "This is Gladlyville," said Elwood, "what's going to happen to him?"
This is where my risk assessment skills break down. In the moment I said lamely, "Someone might pick a fight with him? And knock him down?" He is man-sized these days, almost 5'11", and I don't have the worries about someone physically overpowering him that I do with, say, Petely -- the meek and small-for-his-age 6-year-old. Elwood rolled his eyes. "Yeah, maybe," he said. "That's a remote possibility." What, really, are the hazards? Is walking home at night really any different from walking to the bus stop before sunrise? Are all the good mothers walking their high school freshmen to the bus stop?
I don't know, but I still have a little knot in my stomach.
It is absolutely clear to me that my children should feel comfortable walking to and from school in our quiet and pedestrian-friendly neighborhood. It is equally clear to me that they should feel comfortable walking or biking to friends' houses, even though that's not a risk-free undertaking. I am certain that it is a valuable life skill for my kids to get themselves home from soccer practice on a well-traveled bike path, even though I had to sign a waiver for my 12yo to be permitted to do so in the fall. I reject the oft-espoused idea that parents can't be too careful: of course you can be too careful.
The end goal is to raise kids who make good decisions about keeping themselves safe and who are not hobbled by unreasonable fears. When my son goes off to college in a few years, he will be walking around at night and will need good judgment about how to do it safely. Needless hand-wringing from me will not aid in the development of good judgment.
I'm wringing my hands anyway.
Recent Comments