Bearing-Erin has a post up in response to my "If I Only Had A Brain" lament from yesterday, explaining why she thinks soccer is a Very Bad Choice for large families. Our kids are in soccer for a few reasons:
- They all enjoy it. They never complain about eating dinner quickly to scramble off to practice. They like spending their Saturdays at the soccer field.
- We think team sports will teach our kids lessons that individual fitness activities will not.
- The benefits outweigh the hassles. I don't live in my car -- not even close.
Yesterday's game schedule was the ugliest of the year -- that's six Saturdays in the fall season and six in the spring. This Saturday, for comparison, the boys have games at 9, 9:30, and 10. That we can do. The following Saturday we have games at 1:30 and 2:30. We can do that too.
It would certainly be possible for soccer to take over a family's existence, but I think Erin is throwing out both baby and bathwater here. (Or the soccer socks with the wash water, or something.) We don't do travel teams. We play in a league where the emphasis is squarely on fun, sportsmanship, skill-building, and teamwork -- not winning, not showboating. Parents have to sign a pledge not to be jerky and obnoxious before their kids can play, and mostly it works. There are no games on Sundays, ever. Teams are built based on geography, so that all three practice sites are ten minutes or less from our house. (The 25-minute drive I mentioned takes us to the complex where they all play their games on Saturdays.) This is the sixth year we've had kids in this league, and every single time I have emailed a coach to say we'll be missing a practice or a game, he has responded graciously. It's not a high-pressure high-competition approach to soccer at all.
The reality is that life in a large family is complicated, no matter what activities you choose. I've tried some of the strategies Erin proposes for keeping activity schedules manageable, with mixed success. I've had the piano teacher come to my house for three back-to-back lessons, but keeping the toddler out of the music room and reasonably quiet for 90 minutes isn't easy. I've scheduled swim lessons for all the kids on the same night, but two of my kids have now mastered all the swimming skills they teach at our pool. (Swim team = exponentially more hassle than soccer, IME.) I've put kids into a single martial arts class, only to find that they have different levels of interest and ability and the karate class becomes a source of tension. I'd never say that another family shouldn't do those things -- I'm only saying they've caused me stress just as soccer has.
Making our soccer schedule work requires some creativity for us as a one-car family with kids on three teams. We eat more simple dinners during soccer season. Sometimes I have to ask other families if we can carpool, or if they'll switch jobs with us on game day. If I'm at the field alone with Stella, I can't be the linesperson so I'll try to trade with the person who's slated to bring snacks. Sometimes our soccer players have biked to and from practice, or their siblings have taken the city bus to evening activities because the van was heading to the soccer field.
We also keep tweaking our system. On Wednesday of last week I came home from the evening activities run and I said to my husband, "I am never doing that again." I had taken three kids to overlapping activities -- one to soccer practice, one to karate, and one to CCD. I'm sure there are moms out there who do the same amount of driving around and take it right in stride, but that's not how I want to spend a beautiful spring evening. Elwood said, "I don't blame you." We got out the bus schedule and made a plan: the 14yo can walk or bike to CCD now that it's so light in the evenings, while the 11yo takes the bus to Dad's office so they can walk together to karate from there. I can handle soccer practice, no problem. In fact, taking Stella and Joe to Pete's soccer practice is fun, because they get some playground time together. Stella's a fan of soccer practice despite the carseat time it requires -- all three of the practice sites have nearby playgrounds.
My least athletic son surprised me when he asked to play soccer again this year after a few years away from it. He struggled at first, but he's holding his own these days. It's been fantastic to see him persevere. Another one of the boys has had the same coach for three years now. I love to see how hard he's willing to work for Coach Jon, how motivated he is to get his things together and get his siblings moving so he can be early for practice. My youngest son comes home from every practice full of observations about the other kids and enthusiasm for the team. Registration for for next year was back in February and we asked whether they wanted to play again. All three of them said yes, definitely. No question about it.
I am sure there will be days next year when I feel stressed about soccer. There will be times when I am running late and someone forgot his shin guards and oh wait which uniform was he supposed to wear today and how long has the gas light been on in the van and is it really my turn to bring drinks already? (I hope I won't ever again forget to bring the boy who's got the next game, but I'm making no promises.) We think, though, that the good things about soccer are really good. We think the hassles are worthwhile, even in a large family.
Recent Comments